In a cinematic landscape often dominated by gritty reboots and somber superhero tales, James Gunn’s Superman has emerged as a vibrant triumph, earning widespread critical acclaim and marking a significant milestone for the iconic character.
With an impressive 85% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, the film stands as the highest-rated Superman movie in 45 years, surpassed only by the revered Superman (1978) at 86% and Superman II (1980) at 88%. This achievement signals a bold new era for the Man of Steel, one that critics and audiences alike are celebrating for its heart, humor, and vivid storytelling.
A Look Back at Superman on the Big Screen
To appreciate the significance of Gunn’s *Superman*, it’s worth revisiting the cinematic history of the character over the past four and a half decades:
- - **Superman (1978)**: Directed by Richard Donner and starring Christopher Reeve, this film set the gold standard for superhero movies, earning an 86% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Reeve’s earnest portrayal and the film’s groundbreaking special effects made it a cultural touchstone.
- - **Superman II (1980)**: With an 88% rating, this sequel built on the original’s success, delivering a compelling mix of action, romance, and iconic moments like Superman’s battle with General Zod.
- - **Superman III (1983)**: A sharp decline at 31%, this installment leaned heavily into comedy, alienating some fans and critics with its uneven tone and departure from the character’s core.
- - **Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987)**: Budget cuts and a muddled narrative led to a dismal 14% rating, marking a low point for the franchise.
- - **Superman Returns (2006)**: Brandon Routh’s turn as the Man of Steel earned a respectable 72%, but the film struggled to balance nostalgia with innovation, leaving some viewers wanting more.
- - **Man of Steel (2013)**: Zack Snyder’s darker, more grounded take garnered a polarizing 57%. While visually striking, its somber tone and heavy focus on destruction left many longing for the character’s traditional optimism.
James Gunn’s Superman: A Return to Radiance
Enter James Gunn, the visionary behind Guardians of the Galaxy, whose Superman has been hailed as a refreshing return to the character’s roots. Critics have lauded the film for striking a perfect balance of humor, heart, and heroism — qualities that have been noticeably absent in recent iterations. Unlike Snyder’s brooding, gray-toned Man of Steel, Gunn’s film bursts with bright colors and an uplifting tone that captures the essence of Superman as a symbol of hope.
At the center of this success is David Corenswet, whose portrayal of Clark Kent/Superman has been described as “ideal.” Critics have praised Corenswet for embodying both the awkward charm of Clark and the unwavering nobility of Superman, drawing comparisons to Christopher Reeve’s legendary performance. His ability to convey vulnerability and strength has resonated deeply, cementing him as a worthy successor in the iconic role.
Gunn’s direction has also been a standout, with reviewers commending his ability to infuse the film with the same irreverent humor and emotional depth that made Guardians of the Galaxy a beloved franchise.
The film’s vibrant visuals, witty dialogue, and faithful adaptation of Superman’s optimistic spirit have been cited as antidotes to the overly serious tone of Snyder’s DC films. As one critic noted, “Gunn’s *Superman* reminds us why we fell in love with the character in the first place — it’s fun, heartfelt, and unapologetically heroic.”
Also read:
- MrBeast Launches AI Tool for Video Thumbnail Generation Amid Controversy
- Neuralink to Launch Eye Implant Trials for Vision Restoration in 2026
- Substack Quietly Eyes $50-$100 Million Investment Round Amid Rising Valuation
A New Benchmark for the DC Universe
With an 85% Rotten Tomatoes score, Superman not only outshines most of its predecessors but also sets a new benchmark for DC’s cinematic future. The film’s success suggests that audiences are ready for a return to the brighter, more hopeful storytelling that defined Superman’s earliest screen outings. As the DC Universe undergoes a creative overhaul under Gunn’s leadership, this film serves as a promising foundation for what’s to come.
In a world that often feels weighed down by cynicism, James Gunn’s *Superman* soars as a beacon of optimism. With David Corenswet leading the charge and Gunn’s masterful direction, the Man of Steel has reclaimed his place as a cinematic icon. For the first time in 45 years, Superman feels truly super again.
